A cheesy New York slice pulled from a pie under a neon pizzeria sign
Kill Devil Hills, NC
Real New York style

Sal's
New York Pizza

Blistered crust, real-deal cheese, and a laid-back, open-late room with billiards and pinball. The Outer Banks' corner slice shop.

4.5 / 5 · 568 Google reviews
Why locals keep coming

More than a pie

Veggie

Vegetarian options

Kids

Kids' menu

Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi

Games

Billiards & pinball

Late

Open late nights

"This is true, delicious NY-style pizza, no doubt about it. Waitstaff was friendly and attentive and everything tasted great."
Google review
"The spinach artichoke dip and buffalo chicken pizza was so good. Would definitely go back!"
Google review
"Ordered online and got a call shortly after letting me know my food was almost ready. Asked for our pizza well done and they actually baked it well done!"
Google review